If it's crap ... We'll tell you
FMC posted a status
Gasmacktus - Devourer of Spill posted a status
Dr.Horrible posted a status
Brandon Blaze joined VinnyLT's groupIt's unbelievable how much more praise Empire Strikes Back gets over its sibling films. Everyone only seems to remember the infamous "Luke, I am your father" line, Yoda's gibberish talk, and the Tauntauns. Besides those described items, there doesn't seem to be an overabudance of highlights. I'm here today to talk about the film that I felt was the best of original trilogy and the one that's been spurned by Star Wars fans: Return of the Jedi. When I talk about these films, I will address them in the idea that they are all one long narrative since Empire and Return build off of their previous film.
Why am I writing this blog? I'm bored, got time to waste, and nothing better to do besides continually shoo my dog off of the couch.
Luke Skywalker: Pilot, Jedi, and totally not a whiner this time around...
In Star Wars, Luke was like any teenage kid: looking for adventure and more meaning outside of his normal and, let's face it, boring life as a farmer. Luke rises to the challenge of being not only a reliable pilot, but a learned student of Obi-Wan whose trust in his teachings earn him victory for himself and respect among his peers. In the succeeding story, he becomes a self-entitled cunt of impatience and pays for his reckless abandon of helpful advice with his hand and his sanity. I don't dislike this. Characters change and develop over time, and impatience is sure to follow when your ego has probably inflated to the size of a zeppelin. And in the last movie, Luke finally becomes a man - responsible, thoughtful, and wise. Even Han seems to talk to him like a peer instead of his annoying kid brother. He sees the task before him and contemplates on what to do instead of madly rushing out into the situation like Leeroy Jenkins. Luke even appears to be more level-headed opposed to Obi-wan who only views Darth Vader as a monster to be killed. It's even Luke's selflessness to face his problems alone and rejecting violence at the final moment in his fight against Darth Vader that cement him as a changed man instead of the rash boy we saw in the other films. The reconciliation of Vader and Luke is one of my favorite moments in cinema history and one that never fails to get me every time I watch. Luke be a damn good character, Holmes.
"Leia, darling won't you ease my worried mind?"
Leia was a revolutionary character at the time in cinema. She was strong, independent, and outspoken. But, in the previous films, she was rarely seen outside of her seriousness for the Rebel Alliance. Even with her romance with Han in Empire, the most emotional she ever gets is awkwardly shouting that she loves him. This time around, a new stride of femininity along with her already strong demeanor blend together to give us a more vulnerable character. The distraught situation she creates when keeping Luke's secret from Han cripples her and, for the first time, her emotional barrier is lowered and we see the woman behind all the bravado and brave speeches. She wants to love Han unconditionally, but she's struggling with her responsibilities that keep her from her desires. Plus, Golden Bikini for the Monday-to-Friday win.
Han shot...at some point in time that led to the death of Greedo
Han Solo has been the staplemark bad-ass of the series, and some people incorrectly think that his stature is reduced in this story. In other films, Han is treated like a God. No one can touch him. A smooth panty-dropping line here and a blaster fire there and he becomes an inspiration and an icon. What's different in this film is that, unlike in the previous installments, Han is insecure. Luke's relationship with Leia makes him jealous and angry instead of just being mildly annoyed like with Lando's intruding nature in The Empire Strikes Back. His relationship with Leia is getting serious. It's not just casual fling for Han since it's his love for her that causes him to lash out. What really makes him an infinitely better character is near the end of the film. After the story displays Han as a man who deeply loves Leia, he finally becomes mature enough to tell her that if she wants to be with Luke, then he won't get in the way. This isn't the same Han who had been fighting over her like a horny frat boy in the other films. This is a Han who rises past his own wants to give the woman he loves happiness. Harrison Ford has gone on record saying that he wished George Lucas had killed off his character in Return of the Jedi to have a 'heroic death.' Ford failed to recognize, however, that Lucas and company had succeeded in a more important aspect - finally making Han Solo a mature character.
Yub Nub
This isn't really a story issue, but one of personal preference: I freakin' love the Ewoks. They're supposed to represent the race of beings who are the most unlikely to succeed against the Empire, and they sure do look it; it's not their physical traits, but their tenacity and ingenuity through Guerrilla warfare that save the day. If it was, say for instance, the Wookies fighting on Endor, it would seem like an unfair advantage given their incredible strength. It actually looks like a struggle since the Ewoks are being, sometimes literally, tossed around the battlefield. Some people don't like that they look cuddly and friendly. That just makes 'em freakin adorable. And come on! If you tell me that you didn't tear up a little when that one Ewok was trying to wake up his dead friend, you're lying through your God damn teeth.
Return of the Jedi is the best of the Star Wars films. Not because it's the darkest, but because it's the most mature. Characters overcome their own personal demons and become better, stronger, and more adult individuals by the end.
...
Comment
Comment by C.H. Gorog on July 24, 2011 at 4:32pm
Comment by J Rod on July 21, 2011 at 10:21pm
Comment by X. Just X. on July 21, 2011 at 9:20pm you know what... even with this debate raging, the fact that we can even have this debate leads me to one conclusion:
this triolgy is EPIK!
what a great series. nothing else even comes close. you think 20 years from now people will be having a 3 page discussion over whether Prisoner of Azkaban or Goblet of Fire was a better movie? not even close! IV-VI, baby, all the way...
Comment by J Rod on July 20, 2011 at 11:43pm
Comment by randy on July 20, 2011 at 1:41pm I don't really know if I would call this film underrated, it was a huge hit and is even ranked in IMDB'S top 250 list and was loved by most.
The recent backlash toward it is just one of those things that happens sometimes, I still believe that most people in the world like Return of the Jedi.
If you go and watch Siskel & Ebert's original review, they spend the entire time praising the film like it's a masterpiece of cinema, when they did a review for the special edition in the 90's, all they focused on was how it was the weakest of the 3.
I still think Empire is the best star wars films for sure, but return of the Jedi is a great movie that just made one big flaw with Ewoks instead of Wookies and some people don't seem to be able to forgive that.
Comment by Slusho98 on July 19, 2011 at 6:06pm
Comment by Paul Monroe on July 17, 2011 at 10:07am Well, on my last phrase, I wanted to write instead "... it has the money, the resources and the talent to make it great - which it is".
Sorry for the mistake.
Comment by Paul Monroe on July 17, 2011 at 10:06am This movie is the real deal.
A sci-fi fantasy adventure with a dark side and twists that make it a classic.
The first Star Wars movie is a little campy - a little research shows that the producers of the first movie were not very sure it would be a success.
The Empire Strikes Back is a movie aware and sure of itself - like it knows that its formula work and it has the money, the resources and the money to make it great - which it is.
Comment by X. Just X. on July 16, 2011 at 8:50am
Comment by J Rod on July 16, 2011 at 2:41am Hmm. I'm going to have to go ahead and disagree with you here, C.H. yyyeeah. Okay, no one I know loves the Star Wars saga as much as I do, but even I'm not going to put blinders up to RotJ's flaws. All your points regarding RotJ's strengths are valid, but they can mainly be chalked up to the story, which is awesome btw. Every EPISODE of Star Wars has an awesome story, but not every episode of Star Wars is an awesome FILM. What's the difference? Well, the story is the story. The film is the CINEMATIC EXECUTION of that story. While one can debate whether or not RotJ is a better STORY than Empire, it cannot be denied that Empire is the better FILM. Just can't be.
TESB gets the respect it gets because it is FLAWLESS.
ROTJ may have moments and ideas that are greater than any in Empire (Luke's strength as a character, the redemption of the father, every scene with the Emperor, and Leia's vulnerability), but they are mixed in with a whole mess of other things that clash with the tone of the good things: Jabba's palace, the Ewoks' silliness, the inconsistency of tone, occasionally bored acting, a lack of a major arc for Han Solo (more on this later), the unoriginality of a second Death Star, and just the overall sense of a simpler film than what Empire led us to expect we would get.
After The Empire Strikes Back took us to such dark and contemplative depths, to watch Return of the Jedi do things that even the FIRST film wouldn't do just to bring things back to a lighter mood is inexcusable. RotJ dropped the ball, and one of the biggest ways was in the character of Han Solo.
Originally, he was supposed to die. Imagine, if you will, Lando going down with the Rebel troops on Endor to destroy the shield generator while Han flew the Falcon in the space battle and died in the ensuing explosion. Give him a SACRIFICE! GIVE HIM AN ARC! The Empire Strikes Back had the balls to go places and Return of the Jedi dropped those balls.
And forget the Ewoks being silly! I love them too, but they don't belong IN THE CLIMACTIC BATTLE OF THE STAR WARS SAGA! And what's with the stormtroopers NOT EVEN SHOOTING THEM? That's my biggest problem with Ewoks! "THEY'RE TOO CUTE! DON'T SHOOT!"
© 2013 Created by The Spill Crew.
You need to be a member of The Spill Movie Community to add comments!
Join The Spill Movie Community