The Spill Movie Community

If it's crap ... We'll tell you

Remember James Cameron and his ‘Titanic’ phase? After sinking the ill-fated vessel, making a billion dollars and giving us one annoying catchphrase (“I’m king of the world!!!”) he still wasn’t content. He had to go to the Titanic and make a 3-D documentary about it. At this point he was just shy of raising the Titanic, taking it out to dinner and trying to sink his mast into its boiler room.

With his love for Titanic fully explored, Aliens having petty spats with Predators and his beloved Terminator now governing Cali what was Cameron to do? That’s when you take four years off, pour a big bowl of Frosted Flakes and watch a bunch of cartoons in your underwear for inspiration.


Early responses to the ‘Avatar’ trailer had many fans wondering what Cameron's influences were for the film.

The story centers on a mining company that has set base on the planet Pandora; home to a cat like race of humanoids called the Na’vi. The good natured scientists put their consciousness into genetically engineered Na’vi bodies (Avatars) to peacefully learn about the creatures. The marines use mech suits to blow them away.
Audiences were wowed when they saw the space military machinery. For many it felt like a throwback to the space age machinery we all loved in ‘Aliens’. The Na’vi, on the other hand, were just a little… cartoony.

Some people have taken the Avatar animation rip-off allegations very seriously. Heated discussions continue in forums where fans insist that Avatar stole its plot from this year’s ‘The Battle for Terra’ (or ‘Terra’ as it was originally titled). Avatar was even threatened with a lawsuit form the makers of ‘Delgo’, the animated film that now holds the honor of having the worst opening for a film released in over 2000 theatres.

Now, does the Spill crew think James Cameron would stoop so low as to steal the ideas from lesser known animated films, only to re-package them in shiny new CG technology and make a billion more dollars? Not really. But it does amuse us to think about some of the other cartoons and movies that may have served as his muse.


AVA! AVA!! AVATAR!!! HOOOOOOOO!!!!

What child of the eighties didn’t look at the feline faces of the Na’vi and immediately think “THUNDER… THUNDER… THUNDERCATS! HOOOOOOOO!” Comparisons are inevitable. Both Avatar and Thundercats center on a race of human and cat hybrids. Admittedly the story of the Thundercats is, for lack of a better word, dumb (seriously, read the plot summary on Wikipedia) but fans never watched the show for thought provoking narratives. We watched because the characters looked kick ass. We loved watching the muscular Lion-O, even with his glam rock red mane, wave around the Sword of Omens as he fought off the evil advances of Mum-Ra and his mutant minions. And what 10 year-old-boy, who at school earlier that day declared girls ‘yucky’, went home and secretly lusted for Cheetara? Sure she had a cat face, but damn, she had legs!


So Thundercats comparisons aren’t a bad thing, right? Not when you consider that the 2-D cartoon characters from 1985 look tougher than their 2009 contemporary CG counterparts. Not only does Avatar remind us of a Rankin-Bass cartoon (the company that brought us Thundercats and the 1964 animated classic ‘Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer’) , they also look softer than the characters in that cartoon. While we can picture Lion-O out there bashing mutant skulls, the Na’vi, with their large moist eyes, long skinny arms, and hippie jewelry, look like they should be passing a reefer around in a drum circle. Kumbaya, my lord…Kumbaya.


YOU GOTTA BE SMURFIN’ KIDDING ME

Perhaps the image that elicited the most reaction form audiences is the color of the Na’vi. They're not just blue - they're fluorescent blue. As in glowing, nuclear waste, Aim toothpaste, Gatorade with electrolytes, Aqua Velva blue. If this color were a crayon it would be labeled 'f--king blue’. Not exactly the warriors we expect to see on a distant planet, defending their turf from bad ass space marines.

Let's be fair, though, this is a race from another world. Why shouldn't they be blue? Well, for one, some say it doesn't mesh well with the machinery and realistic grittiness of the soldiers. Maybe if they were given a more natural palette the contrast between the military and the Na’vi wouldn’t be so jarring. Flesh colored skin or even brown and gray fur would add to the illusion of realism. Hey, say what you will about the Ewoks, but those stealthy sonsa-bitches did blend well with their environment.

In the end it is all about writing, and if it’s a captivating story we will, as many a liberal hipster college student might say “not notice color at all. They’re just cool people, man.” For others, they insists we’ll see the Na’vi skipping along hand in hand to battle while boldly singing their war cry. "La la lalalalaaaa... la la la la laaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa..."




DON’T JUDGE A CAT BY ITS COLOR

Let’s face it, most of the keyboard jockeys out there with serious apprehensions towards Avatar are mostly going by one thing – a trailer. Sure, comparing notes between Smurfs and Pandorians are good for a few laughs, but, at the risk of sounding like the Martin Luther King, Jr. of blue cat people, is it right to decide a movie’s failure based on the pigment of its creatures skin? And so what if movies share similar themes or plot? Is Akira Kurosawa going to rise from the grave and finally sue George Lucas for being inspired by ‘The Hidden Fortress’ to make ‘Star Wars’? After all, word of mouth on Avatar has been good.

Even the Spill Crew has seen an early screening, and if it helps the argument about reserving judgment until seeing the film, all we can say is… aw, shucks. We can’t say anything until the release date (it’s awesome!).

Oops. Did we say that?

- Korey, illustrations by Leon

Tags: avatar, james cameron, smurfs, thundercats

Comment

You need to be a member of The Spill Movie Community to add comments!

Join The Spill Movie Community

Tina L. Comment by Tina L. on February 20, 2010 at 6:40pm
WIN!
sam gold Comment by sam gold on February 18, 2010 at 10:52pm
Funny funny article. I always thought the movie was a rehash of Fern Gully, no doubt. (but oh, Tone Loc, where are when we need you????)
Bec B Comment by Bec B on February 15, 2010 at 5:04am
I would suggest for you to read the book the 'color of distance', it is avatar. The aliens are called tendus and link with each other and the environment like those of avatar. the himan element comes in as a fleet surveying the planets and one of them becomes stranded and must survive in their world. it carries many similarities to the ideas of avatar, it's a great read and will draw you in much the same as avatar. i'm not saying cameron 'ripped' the book off, but the similarities are hard to ignore.
cameron barela Comment by cameron barela on January 6, 2010 at 12:57am
look it avsmurf he wont to KILL u hahah
Ese Bobori Comment by Ese Bobori on December 17, 2009 at 2:04pm
and definitely fantastic artwork leon........Finesse
Ese Bobori Comment by Ese Bobori on December 17, 2009 at 1:55pm
lol leon
Rrinman Comment by Rrinman on December 17, 2009 at 1:55pm
Holy crap, great artwork! Awesome job, Leon!!!
Leon Comment by Leon on December 17, 2009 at 1:29pm
Really? Master-Bate, is this how low you are becoming? Choosing the most overly abused joke for a screen name? What, did you pass on "Ben Dover" or "Mike Hunt" or did you just not think of them first? You sound like one of the "keyboard jockeys" Korey was referring to...but then I get the impression you didn't read the whole article, which is annoying...but thanks for the compliment on my art I guess...
Master-Bate Comment by Master-Bate on December 17, 2009 at 11:38am
Really? Spill crew is this how low you are becoming? Posting up an article about an overly abused joke already? I heard this joke a million times its not fun anymore. For the past few months the comparisons for smurfs,thundercats,delgo,terra its been overly used and then here you come again. its getting annoying..but good artwork i guess...
Fungusmonkey Comment by Fungusmonkey on December 17, 2009 at 9:40am
Oh, and to all the people who want to say that this movie or that movie were ripped off from other movies: take a breath and chill out. Most movies and stories are similar to other movies and stories, it's just how storytelling works. Themes and motifs are eternal, and pop up in every piece of great literature. Terminator wasn't ripped off from a book, neither was the Matrix (though it's inspirations run deep). They just seem similar to other works because they share common themes and elements, hence their popularity.

And for the people with the whole "Fern Gully" and "Dances with Wolves" comparisons, it's a a standard plot structure affectionately named "stranger in a strange land" (not to be confused with the book, though that's a kind of example as well). It's basically your standard "guy finds himself in a new environment he doesn't understand, then as he starts to understand it, he seeks to share that understanding with others" plot. You could literally name a hundred different books and sci-fi stories that follow that exact mold - hell, even the Bible has stories like that. The enlightenment of an "advanced" civilization through the acts of a protagonist who has experienced life in a so-called "primitive" civilization is a recurring theme in modern literature.

So, seriously - unless part of Avatar involves Sam Worthington running around saying "Tatonka" or being shrunk down to hang out with flying fairies, you just gotta stop accusing things of ripping off other things and just learn to recognize and appreciate common story elements in film.

Follow Spill!

Latest Activity

3 members updated their profile photos
12 minutes ago
Alex, Darren Duncan, Satoshi Okawa and 2 more joined The Spill Movie Community
16 minutes ago
The Spill Crew added 2 blog posts
23 minutes ago
Lunarthief357 added 5 photos
1 hour ago
Internal Balance Internal Balance is updating our online profile!
1 hour ago
Benjamin David A good artist should be isolated. If he isn't isolated, something is wrong. Orson Welles
2 hours ago
Benjamin David I think an artist has always to be out of step with his time. Orson Welles
2 hours ago
As nate (creator of Robert Kirkman's ''The walking dead'' fans) has disappeared and due to the upcoming premiere of the series on AMC, I will create a new group dedicated to "The Walking Dead", both the comic and the series.
2 hours ago

Music

Loading…

© 2010   Created by The Spill Crew.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service