Because your post was one long sentence with no capitalized letters or periods or commas. Also, it was one gigantic paragraph so I couldn't get through reading it without losing my place.
yeah but Superman Returns (no matter what fans say) was a disaster! First off Superman should have died once the Kryptonite was stabed into him. Second off if the landmass that Luthor created was made of Kryptonite and Superman was weak then there is no way he could have carried it out of the ocean and into Space! GARBAGE! Maybe it wasn't as campy as Batman and Robin but it was far worse then the other Superman films and who knows what direction Bret Rattner would have taken it in. Remember the screenplay for Returns was written by Singer's friends (Michael Dougherty and Dan Harris) who also helped him write X-Men and X2! I understand that a lot of writers and Directors are fans of Richard Donner's SUPERMAN but that doesn't mean we have to continue to follow his story (actually MARIO PUZO'S story)! REBOOT means reboot! Either start from his origin or leave those stories alone and start a new story! X-3 a lot of people give Rattner shit but he was being held down. He wanted to have the Sentiles in the film and have that part of the war and couldn't. Why? Because of the top honcho over at Fox. So when you take out the Director that created the franchise what it is and let Studio Exec's decided who they will hire and who they want in the film....that's when you get garbage!
I wasn't being serious about the keeping the black man down comment. I was really hoping the John Stewart story would have put out a good superhero movie light for the black superhero's. There are plently of superhero's that need to be put out there though, so I agree. Especially one's that are not stereotypical.
I saw both of Burton's Batman movies when they were released, aside from the many, many, many diversions from the comics the biggest issues with these movies is that they are not Batman.
Keaton did a good performance, but no-one in their right mind would think he was perfect for the role of Batman he's just too small. Bale has the psychology and the physicality and he had much better material. He is to Batman what Christopher Reeves is to Superman.
Nicholson never played Joker, he played mob boss who fell into a vat of chemicals. He had none of the Joker's mental aspects (go read Killing Joke by Alan Moore). Worse yet Nicholson ruined a prestigious career with his over the top performance, contrasting with the underplayed performance from Keaton and the script even involved aspects of the comics that only work in cartoons, giant birthday cake!
The mistake that you're making is that you're not looking beyond the surface.
Nicholson > Man falls into vat of chemicals = Comics
Ledger > Man with make up ≠ Comics
But there's so much more to it than that, Ledger (thanks to the material and a lot of prep) portrays the Joker as a human vessel but instead of a soul inside he has the essence of chaos.
Cosmetic changes do not change character, there's a difference between character and characterization. Spider-Man's web shooters becoming part of his body are characterization and it makes more sense for the character, do you expect me to believe that a poor boy growing up in Queens could invent the ultra versatile squirtable glue formula?
Wolverine's costume changing from yellow spandex to black leather makes so much more sense but it doesn't change the character, only a cosmetic change to the surface, which makes more sense in live action.
Nolan and Ledger's Joker goes beyond perfect because he's the best of both worlds, in a real world setting where there are no such chemicals that would bleach skin and yet let you live, he puts on make up and the end result looks cosmetically just like the comics but in terms of plot logic it makes sense within context and in terms of character he's just like the comics.
Since Burton's films were released I have been explaining to people that they were flawed, slowly friends and family have been coming around to how I see the characters. When Begins was released I no longer had to explain why Bale and Nolan had brought Batman to the screen for the first time (technically true as Burton made 2 films about some guy who was obviously not Batman) but friends still said Burton made a good Joker film. They changed their tune when they saw Ledger and argument of how the Joker should be portrayed was finally settled.
I never thought I would need to explain this to anyone but apparently there are some people in the world who actually like the originals.
Old news for the Boy US adapt? Old A-Team to meet New A-Team? Monopoly in Wonderland (Part 2) Trailers & odd topic
Live from the Dresden a few blocks from Mike’s apartment in the Los Feliz, area of Los Angles CA.
IT IS…
THE WEEKENDERS Y’ALL
...
The Prisoner:
Where the fuck did this come from? It debuted tonight on AMC. It is a remake of the popular cult classic from Great Britain in the 60’s that stared the late Patrick McGoohan (hope I spelled that right). The new show stars Jim Caviez...
Man, this review is going to look like crap in comparison to Predator's Batman vs. The Terminator blog.
While everyone knew the first Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare would do well in sales, it's hard to say if anyone could have predicted the epic ...
Comment Wall (12 comments)
You need to be a member of The Spill.com Movie Community to add comments!
Join this social network
Sorry, I'm a grammar Nazi.
meaning why Batman has a sidekick "Let's say I set out to scare criminals not children" that could be the theme!
I saw both of Burton's Batman movies when they were released, aside from the many, many, many diversions from the comics the biggest issues with these movies is that they are not Batman.
Keaton did a good performance, but no-one in their right mind would think he was perfect for the role of Batman he's just too small. Bale has the psychology and the physicality and he had much better material. He is to Batman what Christopher Reeves is to Superman.
Nicholson never played Joker, he played mob boss who fell into a vat of chemicals. He had none of the Joker's mental aspects (go read Killing Joke by Alan Moore). Worse yet Nicholson ruined a prestigious career with his over the top performance, contrasting with the underplayed performance from Keaton and the script even involved aspects of the comics that only work in cartoons, giant birthday cake!
The mistake that you're making is that you're not looking beyond the surface.
Nicholson > Man falls into vat of chemicals = Comics
Ledger > Man with make up ≠ Comics
But there's so much more to it than that, Ledger (thanks to the material and a lot of prep) portrays the Joker as a human vessel but instead of a soul inside he has the essence of chaos.
Cosmetic changes do not change character, there's a difference between character and characterization. Spider-Man's web shooters becoming part of his body are characterization and it makes more sense for the character, do you expect me to believe that a poor boy growing up in Queens could invent the ultra versatile squirtable glue formula?
Wolverine's costume changing from yellow spandex to black leather makes so much more sense but it doesn't change the character, only a cosmetic change to the surface, which makes more sense in live action.
Nolan and Ledger's Joker goes beyond perfect because he's the best of both worlds, in a real world setting where there are no such chemicals that would bleach skin and yet let you live, he puts on make up and the end result looks cosmetically just like the comics but in terms of plot logic it makes sense within context and in terms of character he's just like the comics.
Since Burton's films were released I have been explaining to people that they were flawed, slowly friends and family have been coming around to how I see the characters. When Begins was released I no longer had to explain why Bale and Nolan had brought Batman to the screen for the first time (technically true as Burton made 2 films about some guy who was obviously not Batman) but friends still said Burton made a good Joker film. They changed their tune when they saw Ledger and argument of how the Joker should be portrayed was finally settled.
I never thought I would need to explain this to anyone but apparently there are some people in the world who actually like the originals.
View All Comments