If it's crap... We'll tell you
Can anyone give me reasons Why awesome Superhero comics are clearly superior then lame manga
Replies to This Discussion
-
Permalink Reply by MDS on -
Well, I can't give specific titles.
However, I'll only say this. For the most part the audiences of MANGA readers is completely different than Comics. From what I've seen of the two, Comics sort of go more in-depth than Manga stories do. It's all about the story's targeted audiences.
From what I've heard/read, Comics are meant to be purchased, read, re-read, and stored to keep a reference for later down the line plot and character twists.
Mangas on the other hand, are suppose to be purchased, read, TRADED WITH FRIENDS and therefore are more likely to have a 'throwaway' character or storyline that isn't truly as devoted to the main characters as comics.
Now, that's not saying that one is superior to another. Just that both are intended for different audiences that have different objectives at the time of purchase.
-
Permalink Reply by Rusty Shackelford on -
That's an interesting anaylsis
Yeah also quick question who would win in a fight
BATMAN or Naruto
-
Permalink Reply by Josh on -
To be honest, unless Batman already had a plan in place, Naruto. Come on, the kid can make 100 clones of himself.
-
Permalink Reply by SPAKman619 on -
yes but batman can combat 500 men at once if you have read the comics also its brought up batman begins also if he know how to defeat naruto then he would be able to take on a 100 narutos
-
Permalink Reply by Jon, Chicago's Mindfreak on -
Batman's law: The likeliness of Batman defeating an opponent is directly proportionate to how much time Batman has spent researching the opponent.
Likeliness of Batman's victory= Time spent researching opponent (divided by) the skill of the opponent
-
Permalink Reply by Amanda on -
Naruto is one of the suckiest ninjas in the series though. That isn't Sakura.
-
Permalink Reply by Krzysiekfogg on -
Ok, to be honest I am not a big fan of Manga, but since I lived quite a while in Japan and speak Japanese better than English (I am German though) I feel like I have to comment on some of the stuff you said, from like.. umm.. the Japanese side of things:
MDS "Mangas on the other hand, are suppose to be purchased, read, TRADED WITH FRIENDS and therefore are more likely to have a 'throwaway' character or storyline that isn't truly as devoted to the main characters as comics."
>> while it is true, that Manga are produced cheaper, therefore cost less, and therefore have a kind of throwaway character, you have to consider that EVERYONE in Japan reads Manga. it's not really a geek thing anymore. Manga are everywhere, in newspapers, at the doctor's office, on the train; they are written for pretty much every target group, no matter what age, and therefore are as varied as human beings can possibly be.
That being said, obviously there ARE manga geeks in Japan and they buy and gather pretty tradepaperback version's of Manga as well as the next American or European comic reader and don't throw them away or trade them like stated above
-
Permalink Reply by sinshenlong on -
i agree totally
I find ppl relate more to manga characters as normal people as opposed to super heroes. Maybe because the story's more in depth maybe its the character flaws goofiness Idk thats just what most manga fans think.
Follow Spill on Twitter!
Latest Activity
This is for the planning of a Spill party in Georgia. this is for people who live around and in the Georgia area.
For all those that want to be a clone or just think their awesome
This is for Spillers who like going out regularly like myself. From now on I will regularly organize nights out with other Spillers and we'll do a pub crawl, go bar hopping or go out clubbing. These are not Spill Parties. These are Spill Outs
My father has accidentally spilled the beans; big Xmas Present '09 is an XBox 360! Now, not being the biggest gamer in the world, I wanted to ask for some recommendations. There's a few I already know I want and have told my family about (GTA 4, Bio…
Are you tired of spammers on Spill?
Do you want to play a active positive role in the Spill community?
Well join here and point out the spammers and lets Spam them and kick them off the site!.
Matt, Jack, & Jon are three eloquent young gents. They philosophize, externalize, and harmonize on the most pressing subjects of the modern age. Actually, they mostly just talk about movies and current events, but the presentation is what counts.
This group is for people who want to help and create a spill video game.
For the first time on Spill.Com, Spill Members from Great Britain and the United States bring to Spill a weekly podcast where ALL Spill members are welcome to appear as guests and speak on what's on their minds on Spill and everything else.
Music
© 2009 Created by The Spill Crew
